Which One Should I Go With? Choosing Between Two Options
To choose between two options, first cross off anything that breaks a must-have, then compare what's left on your top value, how easy each is to undo, and which way you lean. Hexagram 17, Following, adds the hard part: you can't keep both, so give the choice to what matters more and stay with it.
Ask the I Ching
Explore this question in your own situation.
Which one should you go with? Start by crossing off any option that breaks a must-have. Then compare what's left on three things: which one serves what you care about most, which one is easier to undo, and which way you lean once you picture the choice as already made. If the two still come out even, both are probably good enough, and the cost of waiting starts to outweigh the difference between them.
A tie like this is tiring. You may have written the pros-and-cons list twice already and watched it come out even both times. Usually that means the list is measuring the wrong things, or that the two options really are close. Either way, there is a way through.
Which one should I go with? Rule out before you compare
Most choices between two get lopsided once you name your non-negotiables. Before weighing anything, write down the two or three conditions an option has to meet: a salary you can live on, a commute you'll actually make, a school that offers the program you need, a partner who wants the same kind of life. Check each option against that list.
If one fails, the choice is made, even if the failing option is the more exciting one. If both fail, the real question is whether there's a third option you haven't written down yet. If both pass, you're choosing between two acceptable paths, which is a better position than it feels like from inside.
How do I choose between two options I like equally?
When both pass, compare them on what's left.
What you care about most. Pick the one value that matters most in this decision, such as growth, stability, time with family, money or freedom, and ask which option serves it better. Leave the overall score aside for a moment. A single clear criterion breaks more ties than a long list.
How easy each is to undo. Some choices are easy to walk back: a class you can drop, an apartment with a short lease. Others are hard to reverse: selling a house, moving a child to a new school. In his 2016 letter to Amazon shareholders, Jeff Bezos wrote that many decisions are "reversible, two-way doors" that can be made with a light-weight process. If one of your options is a two-way door and the other isn't, the reversible one is cheaper to try. If both are reversible, you can afford to decide sooner.
Which way you already lean. Spend one day treating the decision as made: "I'm going with the first one." Notice how that day feels. The next day, do the same with the second. Relief, flatness and dread all tell you something about what you want.
Whether you're holding out for the perfect pick. In a 2002 study, psychologist Barry Schwartz and colleagues found that people who habitually look for the best possible option, whom they called maximizers, reported more regret and less satisfaction with life than people who settle on an option that meets their standards. When both options clear the bar, waiting until you're sure one is the best can cost more than choosing either.
A two-column check
Draw two columns, one per option, and fill in the same rows for each:
| Row | Option A | Option B |
|---|---|---|
| Meets my must-haves? | ||
| Serves my top value? | ||
| Can I undo it? At what cost? | ||
| What I gain | ||
| What I give up | ||
| How the day I "chose" it felt |
The row people skip is "what I give up." Every option has an entry there, and seeing the loss written down in both columns makes the comparison fairer. It is also the row the I Ching speaks to most directly.
What the I Ching says about choosing one path
The hexagram that deals most plainly with a choice between two is Hexagram 17, Following (随, Suí). It is about what you attach yourself to. In my translation, its Judgment reads:
"Great success. Favorable to be steadfast and upright. No misfortune."
Following goes well when what you follow is principled, and when you hold to it once you've chosen. The second and third lines then put the choice in its starkest form.
Line 2:
"If you attach yourself to the young (unworthy), you lose the mature man."
Line 3:
"If you attach yourself to the true man, you lose the youth. In following, whatever one seeks will be obtained; it is favorable to stay at home and persevere."
The two lines mirror each other. Holding on to one means letting go of the other, and the lesson of the second line is that every decision comes with gains and losses. The third line adds the rule for choosing: take the greater and let the lesser go. Once you've chosen well, settle into it and stay steady.
For a choice between two options, that gives you two questions to bring to your table. Which loss can you accept? The "what I give up" row is this hexagram's question in table form. Which option is the mature one, serving the larger and longer aim, and which is the youthful one, appealing mostly for what it offers right now? The lines don't call the youthful option wrong in every case. They say you can't keep both, and that the choice should go to what matters more.
How to ask the I Ching about two options
There are two ways to use a reading here.
One reading about the choice itself. Ask a question that holds both options: "What should I understand about choosing between the offer in Austin and staying in Chicago?" The primary hexagram describes the situation you're choosing in, and the changing lines point to where the tension sits. This suits a choice where the two options are close and you want to see what the decision is really about.
One reading per option. If you'd rather look at each path on its own, ask the same question for each ("What would taking the Austin offer ask of me?") and compare the two results. Should I do it? walks through reading two results side by side.
Whichever you choose, avoid asking "A or B?" as if the answer were a switch. A hexagram doesn't map neatly onto the first option or the second, and forcing it to leaves you guessing. If you want the I Ching's lean on a single option, I Ching yes or no explains how to read a hexagram that way.
On Ask Yi, you type your question, toss three coins online, and get a reading of the result in plain English, with the reasoning laid out. Free, no sign-up.
Example: two job offers
Say you have two offers. One pays more at a large company. The other is a smaller team doing work you find more interesting, for less money. Both meet your must-haves.
Your top value this year is learning, so the smaller team edges ahead on that row. Both choices are fairly reversible, since you could change jobs again in a year or two. The day you spent as if you'd taken the bigger company felt flat; the day for the smaller team felt nervous and alive.
Then you cast one reading about the choice itself, and suppose it gives you Following with the third line changing. The line won't name an offer. It asks you to name what you'd lose with each and to give the choice to the one that serves the larger aim. If learning really is the larger aim, that points to the smaller team, with the salary as the loss you've agreed to carry. If, once written out, the money matters more than you had admitted, say because there's a debt to clear or a family relying on you, then the bigger company is the mature choice for you, and that is just as sound a decision.
For weighing career paths in more depth, see what should my next career move be.
FAQ
How do I choose between two options? Cross off any option that breaks one of your must-haves. If both pass, compare them on your single most important value, on how easy each is to undo, and on how you feel after spending a day treating each one as chosen. Write down what you'd give up with each; the loss you can accept often decides it.
Which one should I go for if I like both? If both meet your must-haves, either is probably a good choice, and waiting for certainty can cost more than the difference between them. Pick the one that better serves what matters most to you right now, or the one that's easier to reverse if you turn out to be wrong, and commit to it.
Can the I Ching help me choose? It can help you see the choice more clearly. Ask one question that holds both options, or cast once per option and compare the results. Hexagram 17, Following, speaks directly to choosing: you can't hold on to both, so give the choice to what matters more and stay steady once you've made it.
Ready to Try a Reading?
Cast coins, get your hexagram, and see the guidance applied to your question.
Start a Free Reading
